Pre-Hispanic agricultural decline prior to the Spanish Conquest in southern Central America

• Lake sediment records reveal patterns of pre-Hispanic agriculture in Costa Rica.
• Stable carbon isotopes and organic carbon abundance are sensitive to agriculture.
• Indicators suggest agriculture ended ∼220 years prior to the Spanish Conquest.
• Timing of agricultural decline is coincident with regional droughts.

Archeological and paleoenvironmental records from southern Central America attribute population collapse to the Spanish Conquest about 500 years ago. Paleoclimate records from the circum-Caribbean have shown evidence of severe, regional droughts that contributed to the collapse of the Mayan Civilization, but there are few records of these droughts in southern Central America and no records of their effects on prehistoric populations in the region. Here we present a high-resolution lake sediment record of prehistoric agricultural activities using bulk sediment stable carbon isotopes from Laguna Zoncho, Costa Rica. We find isotopic evidence that agriculture was nearly absent from the watershed approximately 220 years prior to the Spanish arrival in Costa Rica and identify two distinct periods of agricultural decline, 1150–970 and 860–640 cal yr BP, which correspond to severe droughts in central Mexico. We attribute decreases in agriculture to a weakened Central American monsoon, which would have shortened the growing season at Laguna Zoncho, reduced crop yields, and negatively affected prehistoric populations.